Venue Image

Hours

Daily 11AM-11PM

Nearest Subway Station

Avenue J Station
Avenue J & E 16th St
Q

Parking

at E. 15th Street

Pricing

Low ($)

City's Best

Di Fara Pizzeria   

1424 Avenue J
Brooklyn, NY 11230
718-258-1367

Rating: 4 out of 5  (100 Ratings)   Read Reviews (173)    Rate and Write a Review

About half the patrons of this Midwood pizzeria know pizza-man Dominic DeMarco well enough to call him by name. He's a grizzled old gent, with a deliberate manner and fingertips coated with flour. Regulars come seeking a "one-and-one" -- one ordinary slice; one Sicilian. It's the best way to get to know DiFara's smoky, spare and perfectly balanced pie. The Sicilian cooks in a rectangular baking dish. First Mr. DeMarco spreads a medium-thick layer of dough on the bottom of the dish, adds a little olive oil (nothing too fancy) and a tiny ladle of sauce. When the crust rises to fill the pan, he takes it out, adds more of the fragrant, rosemary-tinged sauce and painstakingly grates fresh mozzarella and two kinds of hard cheese before returning it to the oven for a bit of melting and bubbling. It's an exacting process, so be prepared to wait. If the finished product isn't the best square slice in the city, it's certainly worth a trip out on the Q train to decide for yourself.

User Ratings and Reviews Rate and Write a Review

173 Ratings and Reviews

Order by: Oldest | Newest
user image
Review rating 5 out of 5
yum
By LeeBesser on 07/28/2008
I drive 40 mile from suffolk county and wait over an hour for a pie , but its worth it. Great pizza!!!
KingGama45
Review rating 5 out of 5
Unique pizza
By KingGama45 on 07/25/2008
The regular Di Fara's slice may or may not be the best in the city; it is my own personal favorite. However, it is absolutely unlike anyone else's. Put ten different slices from ten good pizzerias in front of me, and I am certain I can pick out Dominick's. Take the Q train to Avenue J and judge for yourself!
user image
Review rating 5 out of 5
By Ci92000 on 07/25/2008
Jjacks215
Review rating 5 out of 5
By Jjacks215 on 07/23/2008